Why Your SEO Traffic Isn’t Converting

You are here: Home » Knowledge Centre » SEO Knowledge Centre » Why Your SEO Traffic Isn’t Converting

We are rated as the Best SEO and Google Ads Agency of 2024. Check out our Google and Clutch reviews below.

No fixed contract, just MONTH BY MONTH
Affordable and FAIR prices
Fast responses WITHIN hours
We love getting RESULTS
PPC icon SEO icon
Five star rated company ★★★★★
Unable to load widget
GET YOUR FREE AUDIT & PROPOSAL

Why Your SEO Traffic Isn’t Converting

Search engine optimisation (SEO) is the most reliable way to maintain your online visibility. SEO strategies drive organic traffic, improving your rankings in search results, while strengthening your online presence. When done ethically and correctly, it can drive thousands of visitors to your website each month, without any costs for paid advertising.

One of the problems many businesses face is while they show a steady organic traffic growth, yet their website visitors are not converting. Are the analytics showing users are finding your website, but are not taking the next step? Continue reading below to find out why.

Targeting the Wrong Keywords

One of the most overlooked problems in lead generation is targeting the wrong keywords. Most campaigns focus on high search volume keywords, as they drive more visitors. Yes, this will increase your website traffic, but it attracts uses who are not ready to take the next step.

Why Your SEO Traffic Isn’t Converting
GET YOUR FREE ONLINE QUOTE

It is essential your keywords match your users intent. In order to get your website traffic to convert you need to align your keywords with your business outcomes. When you rank for the right searches, the more likely your website visitors will take the next step.

Poor Quality Landing Pages

You may be attracting the right audience, but your landing pages are poor quality, which is negatively impacting your conversions. Most SEO teams will focus on improving rankings, but not what happens once the visitor arrives on your page. 

The most common landing page issues are confusing layouts, slow loading times, and too much text without clear structure, along with weak call to actions (CTAs). In addition to this, if your landing page is missing trust signals such as case studies, certifications or testimonials, it can cause your visitors to bounce, even if they were interested in your services or products.

Content That Doesn't Guide

Your content may rank well as it is educational and comprehensive, but it doesn't guide your visitor to take the next step. Your content must build trust, address your users pain pints, guiding them to an outcome. While your visitors may be absorbing your content, they may be leaving without feeling the need to reach out and make contact. 

Your website content must provide value and point your visitors towards the next step. It's important your content gives your visitors the feeling that you have written the content to help them resolve their problem.

Lacking Trust Signals

Visitors arriving on your website through organic search do not know your brand and may have discovered your website for the first time while researching a solution to their problem. These visitors will hesitate to take action if you are lacking trust signals. Trust signals include client testimonials, case studies, certifications, industry recognition, along with partner badges. 

Trust signals reduce uncertainty, encouraging your SEO traffic to move forward with your brand. 

Weak Call to Actions (CTAs)

Your call to action (CTA) on your web pages are what guides your SEO traffic to convert. Many websites still rely on generic CTAs, such as “contact us,” “learn more,” or “submit.” These lack urgency, where effective call to actions communicate value and encourage the user to take action, such as “get a free quote,” or “speak with a specialist today.”

When you have clear and compelling call to actions positions throughout your web page, it helps to convert passive SEO traffic. Your CTAs must feel relevant and helpful, rather than sales driven, encouraging your traffic to engage.

Technical Issues Negatively Impacting User Experience

Technical issues cannot be seen, but they have a negative impact on user experience, therefore they impact your conversions. Pages that load slowly, forms that are difficult to submit, or checkout processes that are broken can all cause your SEO traffic to give up before taking the desired action. Remember, search engines penalise websites with poor technical health, impacting your rankings and conversions.

We recommend hiring a professional SEO team to help you run a technical audit and fix any problems that could be stopping your SEO traffic from converting. 

Conclusion

SEO traffic is the first step to long-term results. The goal is not only to be visible online, but to encourage your SEO traffic to convert. If your website is attracting SEO traffic, but you are struggling to convert them, the Genie Crawl team are on hand to assist. We provide a tailored approach to SEO, ensuring our strategy aligns with your business, industry, audience and goals. Contact our team now for a free evaluation and quote. Don't get left behind, start converting your SEO traffic today!

RESEARCH
Understanding your market and target audience.
1st step
STRATEGY
Putting together a clear and precise road map.
2nd step
IMPLEMENTATION
Putting everything into practise and making it work.
3rd step
MEASUREMENT
Tracking your success with tools to ensure progress.
4th step
Testimonials

See What Our Delighted Clients Say About Us

Genie Crawl carried out a detailed SEO audit for my tutoring website and explained everything in a clear and understandable way. I hired them straight away and since then I have seen a noticeable improvement in the traffic and leads coming to my website.

Jalisa Ogundelu
Owner

Awesome service, Tony and the team have been great with completing our website and meeting all the deadlines we set. They have lots of bright ideas and created so much value to our business. Our search engine rankings are now on the first page of the Google! We wouldn't have managed this without you guys!

Anna Farra
Owner

Excellent service and great results with our Google Ads account. They are always there at the end of the phone when we need them and they are a friendly bunch of people to deal with. We are very happy with the results.

Olesia Luspa
Owner

Genie Crawl has helped massively with my rankings as a business owner using SEO. My business is doing very well now, all thanks to them!

Daniel Rushton
Owner

Genie Crawl is a very efficient company to work with; they were clear on what they felt they could offer and assisted me in improving my SEO rankings.

Rob Cain
Owner

GenieCrawl was recommended to me for their SEO optimisation services and they have been great to work with. Our traffic jumped straight away and our business has gone from strength to strength thanks to their support.

John Carter
Owner

I was really struggling to get my SEO ratings higher for my business, and my website noticed on google. Thanks to GenieCrawl and their excellent service and SEO knowledge, I was able to increase my rankings sufficiently and am now reaping the benefits of their optimizations. I would highly recommend their service if you are struggling with SEO rankings as I was.

Fynn Healy
Owner

As a new business start up we needed help driving traffic to our website. In all fairness this was an area we were all pretty clueless on. Genie Crawl have been invaluable to us and undoubtedly have been a driving force to increasing sales. They are always there with helpful advice when we need them. Thanks!

Sarah Williamson
Owner

I was a little skeptical about hiring a company to help with the SEO for my website, but I am over the moon with my decision to work with Genie Crawl. They have really increased the traffic to my website and I would highly recommend them to everyone!

Becky Townsend
Owner

Fantastic company. They've been essential in getting us the business that we need. Would completely recommend. We've really found that our rankings have gone through the roof. SEO experts for sure! A+

Lee McRae
Owner
Contact Details

Contact Us

Visit Our Location
US: 244 5th Avenue, New York City, New York, 10001
UK: 120-122 High Street, Whitton, Twickenham, TW2 7LL
Get in Touch

Drop a Line

Complete the form and a member of our team will be in touch shortly to discuss your enquiry.